CS and PS with Taxes

Consumer Surplus and Producer Surplus with Taxes

Before Tax After Tax Change
Consumer Surplus ________ ________ ________
Producer Surplus ________ ________ ________
Government Revenue ________ ________ ________
Total Surplus ________ ________ ________
- Deadweight Loss (DWL) - the change in total surplus as we go from equilibrium to the new point (after tax). It is caused by the loss in consumer and producer surplus due to the lower quantity being produced. The DWL is also called change in total surplus or change in welfare
- The consumer and producer surplus before tax just means at equilibrium.
- Consumer surplus after tax - we only take the area above the consumer's price (which is only triangle A) because only those consumers are still willing to buy the product (at a price of $12)
- Producer surplus after tax - we only take the area below the producer's price (which is triangle F) because only those producers are still willing to sell the product (receiving only $8).
- Government Revenue - this is the tax multiplied by the new quantity ($4 * 15) which is the rectangle B and D.

Example: Tax and Elasticity
Would the Deadweight Loss (DWL) be bigger or smaller in the following situations:
1. Inelastic Supply

If supply is inelastic the deadweight loss will be ________ because the equilibrium quantity will fall by only a little bit.
2. Inelastic Demand

If the demand is inelastic the deadweight loss will be ________ because the equilibrium quantity will fall by only a little bit.
3. Elastic Supply

If the supply is elastic the deadweight loss will be ________ because the equilibrium quantity will fall by a lot.
4. Elastic Demand

If demand is elastic the deadweight loss will be ________ because the equilibrium quantity will fall by a lot.

Laffer Curve
True or False? Increasing the size of the tax will always increase tax revenue - ________
- If the size of the tax is very high, eventually consumers will not be able to afford the product and the amount sold would fall by a lot so the government would end up collecting less in tax revenue.
- Alternatively if the size of the tax is very low, consumers will buy a lot of the product but the government will make very little in tax per unit so tax revenue will be low.
- Therefore a medium tax will usually result in the highest tax revenue for the government.
Laffer Curve - a curve that shows how tax revenue varies with the size of the tax. In the graph below we can see when the size of the tax is in the middle (medium tax) that is the point where the government collects the maximum tax revenue (at a tax size of 20 and tax revenue of $200).
